by Tempest » Sun Apr 10, 2016 8:44 pm
The thing is I wouldn't have any problem with a mod equipped with accounts management powers but limited to recently created accounts (i.e. some sort of "new users" admin) which would be the perfect answer to spambots but that's not possible considering how phpBB is designed. I can create some sort of low-admin/super-mod hybrid but only with full accounts control. Meaning that if deleting massive amount of spam in a single click would be possible, such admin would also be able to delete any/all legitimate users with equal ease. So it's like having an occasional pests problem and having to choose between not changing anything or handing out shotguns... with nothing in between.
Note that this is not really a matter of trust or anything. I make regular backups and I can restore the board if something really bad happen (it usually takes a while but I have scripts to deal with that so I don't really have to remain in front of my computer to do it) but adding admins is usually frowned upon by the Codex of Online Forums.
Basically, this set of unwritten rules states that the number of mod and admin should be kept at a minimum to complete the required tasks with ease and their "privileges" should also be sufficient to accomplish only the said tasks (but no more). Having an admin account means you are also a target for spambots, hack, undiscovered forum vulnerabilities, and so on. Again, I keep an eye on such things and if I feel that my account or the board is compromised, I can log into the server and lock the database while I investigate. I can also access and fix a database directly without even having a functional board. On the other hand, you wouldn't be able to do that.
The thing is I wouldn't have any problem with a mod equipped with accounts management powers but limited to recently created accounts (i.e. some sort of "new users" admin) which would be the perfect answer to spambots but that's not possible considering how phpBB is designed. I can create some sort of low-admin/super-mod hybrid but only with full accounts control. Meaning that if deleting massive amount of spam in a single click would be possible, such admin would also be able to delete any/all legitimate users with equal ease. So it's like having an occasional pests problem and having to choose between not changing anything or handing out shotguns... with nothing in between.
Note that this is not really a matter of trust or anything. I make regular backups and I can restore the board if something really bad happen (it usually takes a while but I have scripts to deal with that so I don't really have to remain in front of my computer to do it) but adding admins is usually frowned upon by the Codex of Online Forums.
Basically, this set of unwritten rules states that the number of mod and admin should be kept at a minimum to complete the required tasks with ease and their "privileges" should also be sufficient to accomplish only the said tasks (but no more). Having an admin account means you are also a target for spambots, hack, undiscovered forum vulnerabilities, and so on. Again, I keep an eye on such things and if I feel that my account or the board is compromised, I can log into the server and lock the database while I investigate. I can also access and fix a database directly without even having a functional board. On the other hand, you wouldn't be able to do that.